JAGTIV · Previous Year Questions

UPSC

ECONOMY · 2011

Previous Year Question

Both Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) and Foreign Institutional Investor (FII) are related to investment in a country. Which one of the following statements best represents an important difference between the two?

A.

FII helps bring better management skills and technology, while FDI only brings in capital.

B.

FII helps in increasing capital availability in general, while FDI only targets specific sectors.

C.

FDI flows only into the secondary market, while FII targets primary market.

D.

FII is considered to be more stable than FDI.

Correct Answer: B

Detailed Solution

Foreign Direct Investment—FDI and Foreign Institutional Investment—FII both represent foreign-capital flows, but they differ in their objectives, duration, control and nature of investment.

Nature of FDI

FDI is generally a long-term investment in a particular enterprise or productive activity. The investor may seek not merely financial returns but also a lasting interest and significant influence in the enterprise.

FDI may take the form of:

  • Establishing a new production unit—Greenfield investment.

  • Acquiring an existing company—Brownfield investment.

  • A subsidiary or wholly owned subsidiary.

  • A joint venture.

  • Strategic equity investment in an Indian company.

In addition to capital, FDI may bring technology, management practices, production techniques, skills and access to global markets.

Nature of FII

FII referred to investment by foreign institutional investors in shares, bonds and other marketable securities. Its principal objective is generally to earn financial returns and construct a market portfolio, rather than to control the management of a particular enterprise.

Such investment may:

  • Increase the general availability of capital.

  • Improve market liquidity.

  • Support valuation and price discovery.

  • Also increase short-term capital-flow volatility.

Testing the options

Option (a) is incorrect. FDI is more likely than FII to bring technology and management skills. It is also incorrect to state that FDI brings only capital.

Option (b) is the best available answer. FII increases the general availability of capital through securities markets, whereas FDI is directed towards an identifiable enterprise, project or productive sector.

The expression “FDI only targets specific sectors” does not mean that FDI is permitted only in a few government-selected sectors. It means that FDI is a direct investment in a specific enterprise or productive activity, rather than general portfolio exposure.

Option (c) is incorrect. FDI does not flow only into the secondary market. It may enter through a new company, subsidiary, joint venture or fresh issue of equity. FII/FPI may invest in both primary and secondary securities markets.

Option (d) is incorrect. FDI is normally long-term and relatively stable. FII/FPI is more liquid and may leave quickly when market sentiment, interest rates or risk perceptions change.

Difference between FDI and FII/FPI

Basis

FDI

FII/FPI

Objective

Lasting interest and influence

Financial return

Investment target

Specific enterprise or project

Portfolio of securities

Management role

Significant influence possible

Normally no control

Duration

Relatively long-term

May be short- or medium-term

Liquidity

Relatively low

Relatively high

Stability

Generally more stable

May be more volatile

Technology/skills

More likely to accompany investment

Normally financial investment only

Current position (2026)

In India, the earlier regulatory designation FII has largely been replaced by Foreign Portfolio Investor—FPI. SEBI introduced the FPI regime in 2014, combining the earlier categories of FIIs, sub-accounts and Qualified Foreign Investors.

Under the current Indian framework, investment in the fully diluted paid-up equity capital of a listed Indian company is generally classified as:

  • FDI when foreign investment is 10% or more.

  • FPI when foreign portfolio investment is below 10%.

The present distinction between FDI and FPI is consequently determined by the ownership percentage, investment objective, degree of control and applicable regulatory route.

Continue practicing free PYQs with your JAGTIV account.